Raw Deal: The Tragic Romance of Robert Walker & Jennifer Jones

[blockquote cite=”The Tragedy of Robert Walker by Jim Henaghan, Redbook Magazine, November 1951″ type=”right”]At the moment of this writing, Robert Walker lies dead in a candlelit room of a funeral parlor just a few miles from where I sit. Dressed in a blue suit, a white shirt and a simple dark tie, he lies silently dead in his thirty-third year. Those who have seen him say he looks at peace, and maybe he is.[/blockquote]

On an unseasonably chilly, rainy evening, smack in the middle of a Los Angeles summer, Robert Walker died in his Brentwood home at the age of 32. His best friend Jim Henaghan, a Hollywood columnist, was at his side along with two doctors who had been called in earlier that evening to help calm the nerves of an emotionally unstable Walker. They had administered a routine sedative, one which Walker had received on several occasions, only this time the actor, who had been teasingly joking with Henaghan mere moments before, stopped breathing.

MGM production chief Dory Schare, who had invested much effort over the past few months in rehabilitating Walker both professionally and emotionally, was called by an inconsolable Henaghan whom he found upon arrival, rocking in a chair, sobbing and shaken. Henaghan had often been the do-as-I-say paternal figure in their friendship and this night, when the doctors had advised it necessary, had forced his friend to take the injection by literally holding him down on the bed.

“I held him down,” said the guilt stricken Henaghan. “I felt like a murderer.”

3,000 miles away, Jennifer Jones was prepping for a trip to the Venice International Film Festival with her husband, David O. Selznick, when the wire came in that her ex-husband, and the father of her two children, was dead. Mrs. and Mrs. David O. Selznick immediately returned to the coast.

The Variety obit read: “Walker, who was climbing back to top attention in a renewed screen career, had completed work Saturday on his last film, “My Son John,” at Paramount. Producer-director Leo McCarey said last night that the film was “Walker’s greatest work.” Son of a Utah editor, Walker won two scholarships to the Pasadena Playhouse while still in high-school. Later he studied at theAmerican Academy of Dramatic arts in New York where he met Jennifer Jones who became his first wife. They worked together at the Cherry Lane theatre in Greenwich Village and later on a Tulsa radio station. Walker made his screen bow in “Bataan” later appearing in “See Here Private Hargrove” and “Since You Went Away” the latter with Miss Jones who at that time was still his wife. They were divorced in 1945 and she married David O. Selznick in 1949.”

Although separated by a divorce of six years and a string of highly disastrous relationships, flirtations and flings (including a brief but violent affair with Ava Gardner during the filming of One Touch of Venus) the truth was that Walker had never got over losing Jones to David O. Selznick. The two had practically been children when they met, not more than 20 each, and fell in love while attending the same dramatic school in New York. One year after meeting they were married, deeply in love and deeply ambitious to make it big on Broadway. What came for Walker was success in radio. What came for Jennifer Jones – then Phyllis Lee Isley — was motherhood. What came for both of them, eventually, was a chance at Hollywood. It proved to be the beginning and the end. The beginning of two sparkling screen careers– Phyllis born again as Jennifer Jones and netting an Academy Award for her screen debut, and Walker making a mark as the ultimate boy-next-door.




Effects of the divorce.

And while Walker was a genuinely kind-hearted fellow, his “gosh-gee-fellas” demeanor on screen belied the rebel beneath. It took the unexpected atom bomb of a divorce to bring those dark, haunting ghosts (with him since his ne’er do well days as a military cadet) to visceral fruition.

Much in the same way that the soon-to-be-famous method actors Brando, Clift and Dean would outwardly buck the system, Walker was in every way a Hollywood rebel. He never wanted to be a “movie star”, and when he became the victim of a systematic plot by an obsessed David O. Selznick to possess Jennifer Jones at any cost, his indifference toward Tinseltown became acerbic.

Selznick produced the poignant wartime melodrama Since You Went Away during the traumatic climax of their divorce, of which he had been the careful orchestrator, and refused to recast Walker. Selznick not only insisted on Walker playing Jones’ ill-fated love interest, but personally oversaw some of the most gutwrenching dialogue between the two lovers.


Walker and Jones in Since You Went Away.


Walker on the single scene.

Not long after, Modern Screen magazine ran the story “The Mystery of Bob Walker”:

“Consider the mystery of Robert Walker, one of the strangest men in 
Hollywood. He’s a guy with a million romances, but they say he’s 
still in love with his ex-wife. He’s a man who wants to act, but 
he’s turned down parts any other actor would have hocked his soul 
for. (A lead in ‘State of the Union’, for instance.)”

“He’s disappeared for long stretches at a time, and neither family, 
friends nor studio could track him down, or lure him back.”

“He’s behaved at all times the way he’s felt like behaving; he’s 
never conformed, he’s never tried to.”

“He went straight to the top, stayed there a while, and then very 
calmly walked out. Nobody in Hollywood understood Walker but that 
wasn’t strange, because Walker didn’t understand himself.”

“A few months ago, he went to the head men at Metro-Goldwyn-
Mayer. “Take me off the payroll,” he said. “I’m through with movies 
for good.”

“Listen, Bob,” one of them said, “take some time and think it over. 
Go to New York, do a play — but quit talking nonsense. Hollywood is 
where you belong.”

“Walker shook his head stubbornly. “Take me off the payroll. I’m 
not working, and I’m not going to work.”

“You can’t work for any other outfit,” he was warned. “Your contract 
belongs to Metro.”

“I understand that. I’m not asking you to tear up my contract. I 
just want it clearly understood that as far as pictures are concerned 
I’m all washed up. Through.”

He wasn’t, of course.

And although a propensity for drink did not in any way help his emotional state, MGM still held on to him as a worthwhile property. The new MGM production chief Dore Schary took a particular interest in Walker, dedicating much time and effort in rehabilitating Walker personally as well as professionally. As Walker’s spells of melancholia and emotional outbursts were becoming more frequent, they were also becoming decidedly more violent: random vocal tirades (according to Henaghan they would be having a normal conversation when suddenly Walker would cry out; “DAVID O. SELZNICK!”) and unexpected fits of rage that resulted in him smashing his fists through walls or windows. (After interpreting a casual flirtation by Ava Gardner into something more, he struck her across the face during a heated argument. They finished filming without speaking to each other again.) Increasingly emotionally fragile, it was following Walker being booked for drunk and disorderly conduct (which resulted in an embarrassing photo that would be seen ‘round the world) when Schary forced him to seek psychiatric help at Meninger’s Clinic.


“I thought of a mental institution like an insane asylum,” Walker said in 1949. “Fear hit me. I thought that someday soon I was going to end up dead.”

It is impossible to be sure, but perhaps it was this well-publicized sojourn at Meninger’s  that led to Alfred Hitchcock casting Walker completely against type in the psychological thriller Stranger’s On a Train. Whatever Hitchcock’s reason, it is well documented fact that Walker was his ONLY choice from the very beginning to play the charming sociopath Bruno Anthony. The result was a chilling, disturbing, and altogether perfect performance by a deeply nuanced Walker who not only carried the film but walked away with it completely.


As Bruno Anthony

Director Leo McCarey’s deafeningly Anti-Communist soapbox of a film My Son John followed and, although Walker was highly dissatisfied with the way the shoot was going, his career looked to be on the mend. Being a father had become especially important to Walker as he would race home after a day’s filming to have as much quality time with his two sons as possible. And although dealt a blow by the swift wedding between Selznick and Jones, Meninger’s friendship had indeed done Walker good. He’d entered a new phase of his life, not as a mere studio “property,” but an actor in his own right. The fact of which made Walker’s untimely death that rainy night all the more tragic.

“Bob’s death was such a waste,” Schary commented. “He was a talented actor and a man who simply switched onto a siding and ran into a dead end.”

Henaghan penned an in-memoriam of his dear friend just days after his death– a self-admitted catharsis– nursing his wounds with prose. Walker was a man understood by few, which compelled Jim Henaghan, the only other person to understand him as well as Jones, to pen his 1951 Redbook eulogy:

I poured myself a drink and went into Bob’s bedroom. They had covered him with a blanket. I uncovered his face, straightened his head, closed his eyes, and smoothed his hair, for he was a vain man and I knew he would have wanted to look as good as possible when they came for him.

I sat alone with him for half an hour and spoke to him as though he could hear me. I wanted desperately to call him buddy just once more and to have a last laugh with him. Then I remembered an outrageous running joke we had shared for many years.

It was our private joke. He would see me with a new pair of cuff links, and he would cry, “Those are mine! You stole them from me!”

I would look through his record collection, and I would scream that the records were mine and that he was gradually looting me of all my possessions. I remembered that one night, when he had stayed at my house, he had said:

“If I were to die in this house tonight, the first thing you would do is steal my money.” And he sat on the stairs and laughed for ten minutes at the thought.

I got up from my chair and picked his trousers. He had no money in the pockets. So I stole his watch.

I covered his face again, but I am sure I could hear him yelling at the top of his lungs, “You——–! I told you! I knew you’d do it!”

With the sound ringing in my ears, I left my friend’s body and his house and I’ll never go back.”


  1. I enjoyed this article very much. I had just finished watching a film with Mr. Walker and was interested in learning what had happened with Jennifer Jones. May he rest in peace great actor taken far to early

    • It’s actually a little messy. He was an alcoholic (and prescription pill abuse) and perhaps mentally ill. In the 1940s they talked of “outbursts”. What does that mean? Well, he would get angry, he would cry, etc. Is that mentally ill or someone going through a tough time in life. In any case, he had an “outburst”, cried for hours and a psychiatrist was called to where he was staying. They had to hold him down to give him tranquilizers and he either had an allergic reaction or they gave too much. Either way he was dead in minutes and his friend, who helped hold him down, never forgave himself, believing he helped “murder “him. Just a messy, tragic affair, like his life.

  2. He died in his early thirties yet in his last movie roles he looked like a man of 50. The sorrow and heartbreak of his life was etched in his handsome face.
    What a shame, and what a waste. He was a fine actor and although I didn’t know him I imagine he was a very sweet man.

  3. Robert Walker was a brilliant actor. Had he not lost his life, he would have gone onto do such amazing films. I am sorry we lost him at such a young age. RIP Sweet prince.

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. Favorite films: Miracle in the Rain (1956) – Champagne for Lunch

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.